



Kill Bill cannot be a cult classic because Q was already established by then. Reservoir Dogs is more of a cult classic. Clerks II doesn't count because Smith is established as well. The only films of his that CAN be cult classics are Clerks, Chasing Amy(a rebound after a flop), and Jersey Girl(ate it in the theatres). Just being an indy film doesn't make it "cult." It has to, on some level, take itself seriously. That is where SOAP fails. It new from the start that it was a shit premise, so I went out and said "We are a cult film. Come watch us!" If people come watch you, then you are not a cult film. Sorry. That is how it works. Sorry if I take this a little too seriously, but this is a genre of film that I love. I love going to stores and looking through DVD bins for $3 movies I haven't seen. Then I wait, and three years later it makes a comeback.GuyvarIII wrote:
I haven’t seen Snakes on a Plane (I'll wait for the DVD).
But hasn’t this instant cult classic thing been done before? I don't like it but Tarantino's Kill Bill was manufactured to be, and was praised by the critics as, an instant cult classic. Why shouldn’t the same thing work for Snakes on a Plane?
I’ll let my cel gallery speak for my love of cheesy action.
I never said those films were not cult classics? They certainly are. I think the idea of Indy and Cult films are being mashed together. A film can have a studio release and still be cult. Jersey Girl is a cult film because it was panned by critics and ignored by even his most rabid fans. I just don't think you can release a film and call it "cult." It has to develop that title on its own. It's like releasing a film and calling it an "instant classic." That is impossible. For it to be a classic, it has to stand the test of time. SOAP never took itself seriously, it had a great deal of hype and success, and therefore is not a cult film. How can it be "cult" if the majority of America knows about it right from the start? Those three Raimi films are cult films because they were not successful releases, they had comedy(but still took themselves seriously as films in their genre), and had a largely unknown cast and crew. For goodness sake, the most famous actor in Darkman when it came out was Larry Drake!wELCOME cONSUMER wrote:Evil Dead, Army of Darkness or even Darkman are not cult classics?![]()
I dunno, I still think you're overthinking this. The Evil Dead movies did not
take themselves seriously and they're definitely cult classics. Rami was not
established for a long long time. Jersey Girl could never be a cult classic
because Smith was a total Hollywood sell out by that point (you see that
in the end of Clerks 2 as well, the guy just can't escape it).
SOAP isn't movie of the year material. But I like to laugh and this movie
made me laugh. I don't see the harm.
I agree, but it's still fun to debate.HotIce wrote:am i the only person thinking 'who cares what label a movie has as long as you enjoy watching it?' =\