I just watched the Clannad movie (spoilers beware)

Topics on anime/other animation TV series, OVAs, specials, and movies
Post Reply
User avatar
darksuzaku
Kishin - Fierce God
Posts: 493
Joined: Sun Aug 15, 2004 6:03 pm
Location: Spain
Contact:

I just watched the Clannad movie (spoilers beware)

Post by darksuzaku »

Following Keropi's advice i waited to watch the movie until the series was over, and in part i'm thankful for that advice.

Before watching the movie i thought it was going to be like the Air movie, i mean, a retelling of the same story of the series.

How mistaken i was.

While the movie and the series share many common aspects their plot varies in many key aspects.

For example, i would say that the personalities of Nagisa and Tomoya are swapped in the movie. Nagisa is the cheerful one while Tomoya is the shy one that lets himself be carried away by the cheerful Nagisa.

Some characters from the series don't appear on the movie, (the movie was done earlier than the series, so more characters were added for the series to have more plots). But for once, Sunohara has in the movie a more active role than in the series.

The drama club solo act at the festival is done perfectly in the movie by an awesome Nagisa. And the climax scene when Tomoya realizes that Nagisa and himself are having the same dream and he declares to her...... that's the best of the entire movie.

The rest of the movie, well, what can i say, that's the reason i'll probably never watch the movie ever again..... Don't misunderstand me, it's a perfectly well done ending, but sad stories make me feel depressed for longer time than i would like, specially when i really love the characters. At least, the very end is happy when Tomoya catches Ushio on his arms and she calls him "papa".

So, what's better, the movie or the series?... Difficult question. Trying to see this from an objective perspective i really believe that the movie is better. But of course the series has many more plots that are not present on the movie. (i guess those extra plots were extracted from the game but i can't be sure o that as i have not played the game). As for the music, i prefer the versions of the op/ed songs in the series, and of course the graphics of the series are better.

Anyone would like to share their thoguhts on this one? :)
User avatar
Keropi
Bishoujo art collector
Posts: 5602
Joined: Fri Jul 04, 2003 2:10 am
Location: Southern California

Post by Keropi »

After people started speculating if there's going to be another series (TV or OVA) to cover the ?third gaming story arc of Clannad, I decided hold off watching the Movie for now.

I'm rather bothered by how Kyou, Ryou and Tomoyo's stories were handled in the TV series. :(
User avatar
Kujaku
Kuwabarakuwabara - Oh My God!
Posts: 600
Joined: Sun Jan 23, 2005 12:36 pm
Contact:

Post by Kujaku »

Does anyone know anything about the Clannad ~After Story~? I watched the promo, is this something like the air specials?
User avatar
Keropi
Bishoujo art collector
Posts: 5602
Joined: Fri Jul 04, 2003 2:10 am
Location: Southern California

Post by Keropi »

Kujaku wrote:Does anyone know anything about the Clannad ~After Story~? I watched the promo, is this something like the air specials?
People are speculating that it might possibly be a thirteen episode TV series that covers the third story arc of the Clannad game.

The Clannad TV series (episodes 1-23) would be as if we only got the first two story arcs of the AIR TV series and didn't get the third story arc of AIR when all the dramatic events occurred and the explantions were given. The "Clannad ~ After Story" would cover the third story arc when supposedly the most interesting events happened.

At least that's what I heard. I know little about the game. Supposedly the game stories in Clannad were so long that people were always wondering how the anime producers were going to fit everyone's story satisfactorily into a roughly 24 episode TV series.

The answer was....they didn't even try.
Image
Post Reply